Are We Free to Choose?

Lire ce texte en français →

Several million years separate us from the first humans on earth. This difference of era is tempered by one fact: we are the victims, if not the heirs, of our predecessors’ choices. When we choose to live in one place rather than another, for example, we do not know it, but we have just shaped the life of a man or woman who will be born two or three centuries after us.

What would the American continent be today without Christopher Columbus’s expeditions? What would Africa be today if the slave trade had not taken place? I could not answer these two questions or thousands of others of the same kind. So as not to waste time on such futile questions, we can now turn to our own era, more precisely to the choices we make and the choices we will make tomorrow.

Choice.

Is the word “choice” not a simulacrum of freedom? In making a choice, we favor one thing at the expense of another; we cannot do or have both at the same time. Sometimes choice is even the negation of freedom: when we are forced to choose one thing among several, the moment we make our choice, we give up our freedom. The question then arises: can we have everything? The answer is no, because in a society with more or fewer people, no one can grant themselves the privilege of having everything without reducing their fellow humans to slavery. Since we cannot have everything, we must make a choice, provided we have the freedom to choose.

low section of man against sky
Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com

Is choice not the absence of freedom?

What, then, is freedom?

Here is a question that deserves a whole lifetime to answer. If I venture into it, I would say that freedom is the ability to be, to do and to dispose. This is a very broad view of freedom that does not lack critics. Indeed, with this definition it is hard, even impossible, to reconcile freedom with other notions. Let us show this difficulty with two examples. First, if we consider equality with all it implies, the ability to dispose is reduced, since no one can dispose of more than others. Second, if we consider social life, we can all agree that the ability to be is limited, since no one can claim to be exactly as they wish in a more or less organized society.

The definition of freedom above therefore seems inadequate; we can still adapt it by saying that freedom is the ability to be, to do and to dispose within the limits of what is permitted. Two consequences follow: first, we are free because it is permitted, so we must ask who in society holds the power to permit. Second, since freedom is in principle limited, we cannot dispose of it, only exercise it.

If we are bound to exercise freedom within the limits of what is permitted, then we are free to choose within the limits of what is permitted. The question then returns: who has the power to permit in society? I will not try to answer it, so as not to stray from my main aim. Still, we can observe that our freedom of choice is, a priori, limited.

In truth, we cannot accuse today’s society of limiting our freedom of choice; this has been the case in every era. Freedom of choice is limited either to favor the common interest of society’s members or to prevent one individual’s choice from harming the rest of the community. However, it is not surprising that whoever holds the power to permit, and therefore to limit freedom of choice, may do so in their own interest.

Have I been able to answer the initial question?

I leave you all the freedom to decide for yourselves, or to complete my answer if you wish. In any case, I believe I have given you elements for a mature reflection on the subject.

Written by Divin Garnaud Irakoze.

 

Translated from the French original, “Sommes-nous libres de choisir?”.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.