Failure
What is failure, if not a feeling of dissatisfaction? This definition is no doubt marred by inaccuracy as well as imprecision. To remedy this, I would say failure refers to two things: failure can be experienced personally, or it can be held against us by society.
If failure is personal, it can be defined as the feeling of non-success, or simply as obtaining a negative result. We can now compare the two definitions and then reconcile them. If failure is a feeling of non-success, this implies that in the same situation there could have been success; failure is therefore defined in relation to another situation. Conversely, if failure is obtaining a negative result, the adjective “negative” brings us back to a comparison between two results; failure is thus felt as falling short of people’s logical and probable expectations.
Take the example of a diligent student who gets a below-average grade on a test. It is automatically labeled a failure because the grade is below a certain threshold, but there is also a psychological factor we must consider. If the student usually got very high grades, when they get a lower grade than usual they may easily call it a failure; conversely, a grade automatically labeled a failure may be seen by the student as a success if it marks progress for them.
If failure is held against us by society, we must first point out that the notion of society is very limited in time and space, and that the notion itself is limited to society’s moral judgments.
Society can reproach us for a multitude of things. What it reproaches us for is the result of its fears and turmoil, but also of its moral convictions.
Take the example of a Rwandan woman who becomes pregnant before marriage: Rwandan society considers this a failure both of the woman herself and of her family. Two remarks are needed to criticize society’s view:
First, a healthy woman becoming pregnant is nothing abnormal; it is natural. It follows that a society that considers having no offspring a failure is in no position to consider this situation a failure.
Second, this failure is driven above all by fears of Rwandan society that have no basis in the 21st century, namely fear of others’ judgment or fear that the pregnant girl will struggle to find a husband.
Failure can be either personal or a reproach from society. Personal failure implies a material element but also a psychological factor. As for failure born of society’s reproach, it stems from society’s fears or turmoil. Since it is a reproach from society, it has nothing logical about it; it simply implies society’s moral judgment on a specific question.
Written by Divin Garnaud Irakoze.
Translated from the French original, “L’échec.”.
