I Don’t Know How to Pray, I Only Know How to Speak
The older I get, the less naturally recited prayer comes to me, as it once did. No doubt because today I mix belief with reason more. No doubt also because doubts I did not know as a child have crept in with age. I can no longer pray without asking myself why I pray, what I really believe and what my words mean.
I remember the years when I thought that if I did not do the good the Church asked us to do, I would go straight to hell. I was afraid, but I did not really know whether I was afraid of evil or simply afraid of God punishing me. Fear of hell was sometimes enough to keep me from sins that, in my child’s mind, I did not find so serious. Stealing a little sugar, disobeying because I was tired: those were the kinds of faults that could already trouble my conscience.
Childhood perhaps makes it easier to accept what adults present as truths. I thought they necessarily knew better than I did and that it was better to follow them than to question gestures I still understood mainly as acts of faith. At home, piety was part of daily life. Sunday Mass was a given; weekday Masses were almost a family appointment. I was a child of God. That was really the only world I knew. I was applying for Heaven and I worked at it seriously. Those who did not live as we did were, in my eyes back then, in error, while we walked the right path.
Then childhood and adolescence drifted away. I had to become an adult. And life led me to a world very different from the one I grew up in: the West, France, a society where religion determines neither a person’s worth nor necessarily the path they should follow. There I discovered that some values I spontaneously associated with faith could exist far from the Church, carried by people who did not believe or who believed differently. I saw convictions I thought unchangeable being discussed, deconstructed, questioned again. Religion, sexuality, human relationships, sensitivity: everything seemed open to question.
I sometimes felt myself wobble before this new, dizzying freedom, where one could become almost anything, including what I had long considered taboo or simply impossible. My truth was not other people’s. My belief was not theirs. What I could fight for was sometimes precisely what they rejected. For a while, I felt I had arrived in a mad world, and that feeling made me mad with worry.
How were we going to live together? To live together, you must at least learn to get to know each other. To get to know each other, you must open your heart. And to open your heart, you must grant the other the right to be different. But how do you do that when what I consider a sin is, for the other, an essential part of their truth? How do you accept not correcting them? And conversely, if what I deeply believe is precisely what the other rejects, how can I believe they might still understand me? These questions long remained without a real answer.
The years went by. My certainties kept wavering, but one conviction remained: as long as humans do not know everything, God will remain master of my existence. It is not because He is contested, nor because He escapes our eyes, that He stops existing for me. My faith also rests on the idea that human beings do not have all the answers. Perhaps a creature cannot wholly contain its Creator, nor claim to understand Him in His entirety.
So I kept going to Mass, sometimes without the fervor of the early days, but with the conviction that it was not in vain. When I still lived in my parents’ house, missing Mass seemed almost impossible. Here, my relationship with the Church has loosened without disappearing. My faith in God remains, even if it no longer quite resembles that of the child I was.
I learned to make my religious convictions more personal. I also learned to admit that my truth is not necessarily my neighbor’s. Perhaps my role is not to impose what I believe to be good or evil, but to try to live, myself, according to what I believe is right. Am I wrong? Perhaps. Am I right? Perhaps too. I do not hide my faith, but I no longer try to impose it. Sometimes I doubt, sometimes I rejoice. Sometimes I feel deeply in communion with God; other times, it is the abyss. Life is like that. So is my faith.
I still very often take time to reflect in prayer, but I must admit it: I no longer pray as before, neither in intention nor in manner. Words learned by heart are less enough for me. Certainties have grown rarer. My prayer has perhaps become less perfect, less orderly, less sure.
I do not always know how to pray.
I only know how to speak.
Igihe kimwe Yezu yari ahantu asenga. Arangije umwe mu bigishwa be aramubwira ati: “Nyagasani, Yohani Mubatiza yigishije abigishwa be gusenga, natwe twigishe gusenga.” (Luke 11:1: “One day Jesus was praying in a certain place. When he finished, one of his disciples said to him, ‘Lord, teach us to pray, just as John taught his disciples.’”)
Written by Aliane UMUTONIWASE
Translated from the French original, “Je ne sais pas prier, je ne sais que dire”.
