Who Can Deny It?
Do you believe in destiny, in fate?
We are born with at least one common destiny: to die. In that sense, yes, I believe in destiny. From our very entrance into life, we are already moving toward an end we did not choose.
Even when human beings try to decide for themselves the moment of their death, they do not thereby become masters of their whole destiny. They control neither the circumstances of their birth, nor all the wounds, encounters, losses or events that have shaped their existence. They can sometimes act on the course of their life, but they never fully command everything it is made of.
Bossuet wrote: “I enter life with the law of leaving it.” This sentence sums up something deeply human: we enter existence with the certainty that one day we will have to leave it.
For a long time, societies lived more with the idea of an almost unchangeable order. Birth often determined a considerable part of one’s existence. The father’s trade could become the son’s; poverty was passed on more easily, and so were privileges. One inherited a place in the world as much as a name or a family.
Today, at least in some societies, this idea of fate has receded. The world remains deeply unequal, but paths have become more mobile. You can change jobs, go back to school, leave a milieu, start a new life, invent an identity that does not quite match the one you seemed destined to receive.
Merit, will, encounters and circumstances thus compete with the idea of a destiny entirely written in advance. We do not always become who we were supposed to be. Sometimes we can become who we choose to be.
The world has changed, and many boxes have opened, shifted or broken. All these possibilities make us want to believe that life is not only a matter of destiny.
Perhaps it is rather an experience whose ending we know without knowing the story.
The end remains certain.
Everything else is negotiated with chance, our choices, our possibilities, our limits, other people, and sometimes what we call destiny.
So life has the last word. One day it will strip us of what we thought we owned and hand us over to death.
But between the entrance and the exit, there is a space.
Perhaps that is where our freedom lies.
We do not decide to arrive.
We do not always decide to leave.
But between the two, we can try to live.
Written by Aliane UMUTONIWASE
Translated from the French original, “Qui peut le nier ?”.
